We Can Decentralise The Police Without Compromising National Security - Mike Igini

// Latest Addition | We Can Decentralise The Police Without Compromising National Security - Mike Igini
Email to a friend Plain text Print version // Font size: Decrease font Enlarge font

MIKE Igini is the Cross River State Resident Electoral Commissioner. In this interview, he calls for the decentralization of the policing system in Nigeria,saying it would help nascent efforts at fighting insecurity.

photo


The failure of government at all levels to provide security has generated questions on what public officials like the president and governors do with security vote.
Indeed it is time to ask those questions, but apart from asking such questions, we also must start from the very conception of security needs as it pertains to our current needs. It is clear from the outcome in terms of security that much is being done, nevertheless whatever is being done has not been sufficient. But then it must be noted that where as there are two tiers and a local government structure of governance and we are concerned about failure of security of lives and property, it is first a failure of the LGA and state structure of governance before the tier of government that is far away.

In order of priority, we can say that we have three key security exigencies, namely the violent insurgency of the Boko Haram sect, its consequences on especially the North East geopolitical zone and the rest of Nigeria, and the rampant cases of kidnapping and the growing cases of vandalization, bunkering cum theft of crude and refined oil products. While these are top on the list, there are many other issues of security which also need to be addressed. In terms of conceptualization, therefore, we need to take a deep thought to ask ourselves about how these problems came about, why they are persisting and what can be done to eradicate or contain them. These matters require not only security hardware but also security, administrative and social software.

The disposition of the civilian democratic dispensation to solving such problems must not be as knee-jerk as the approach of the military dispensation which, being a reflexively law enforcement arm, will normally think mostly about containment and control. Under a democratic dispensation, the plural dispersal of powers between different arms of government requires more sensitivity to decisional inputs and a better understanding of the preventative aspect of insecurity which often has its roots in social maladies.

So taking these priority issues, for instance, how much of security vote is expended on understanding the problem before or after reacting to them?
Kidnapping and oil theft, for instance, require significant use of transport and communication resources, what are the gaps in the system that sustain such crime, how has the system dealt with the collaboration of security personnel and sometimes members of society who are involved with undermining the system? More importantly, when culprits are apprehended, what consequences do they face? Similarly, regarding the Boko Haram insurgency, while many people have roundly condemned the modus operandi of the insurgents, we also need to ask why the sudden upsurge of such a fundamentalist fervor and how does it find home among people who have not been deprived the right to practice their religion with tolerance of other faiths for many decades? While we prevent and remedy security problems, we should also ask if we have made room for rehabilitation of those in society who have been forced to create insecurity because there were no social safety nets to avoid doing otherwise, to do so is in our enlightened self-interest.
Mike Igini

Mike Igini

All these unanswered questions tell us that, while it is very important to have the security hardware to deal with widespread eruptions of insecurity, more often than not, a greater aspect of such expenditure should be preceded by security software requirements, a common agreement on social values and what levels of deviation are tolerable, professional security analyses, social analyses, the involvement of a wider aspect of society and eventually near accurate application of force where needed, as well as the application of administrative and social remedies. To do these things you cannot have the elite which considers security vote as a budgetary sleight of the hand, or the consequences will come home to roost. We therefore need a complete shift of mind-set on security at all levels both from leaders and the larger Nigerian society.

 Kano State governor, Rabiu Kwakwanso, last year, said he had stopped receiving security vote, describing it as a smokescreen to divert public funds. Does this not conform with the mood of the people that security vote has not secured the citizenry

As I said earlier, much may have been done, but as long as the conditions remain insecure, all such efforts will be perceived as insufficient, because security is a binary conception. It has only two acceptable variables, secure or insecure, there is no middle ground. Unfortunately, Kano does not rank as one of the safest states these days, I would have said the governor made a very wise decision; nevertheless, it hardly matters how much is allocated to security if the outcome is ineffective.The concern of Nigerians has not been so much the amount allocated as the opacity of the process of utilizing such allocations effectively. If you say you want money to build five warships to go to war and the soldiers get to the war front to find only two ships with half the troops stranded, your own soldiers will kill you first before the enemy.

Importantly, we must keep the goal of security in mind, which is to be secure, all cases of insecurity do not require the same approach hence the quality of decisions taken is key. To divert important resources away from security is suicidal for any leadership at any level because security is the principal reason people come together to form a state. I believe the key concern of Nigerians is value for money, which boils down to three Es, namely, efficiency..maximization of security benefits from inputs, effectiveness and efficacy of security decisions and resources used.

 As a lawyer, given that security vote is not provided for in the constitution, don’t you think it is high-time that the spending is outlawed?
What is unconstitutional is unlawful, I do not subscribe to any form of appropriation that is not vetted, it may be done before or after it has been applied depending on the need, but it should be susceptible to scrutiny if not by a large group but by at least a specialized group, the core motivation of democratic leadership is the necessity to be accountable to electors or the representatives of the electors.

At a recent forum, Edo State governor, Comrade  Adams Oshiomhole, argued that fighting insecurity does not end at having huge security vote, adding that there are  constitutional flaws like the inability to truly function as a chief security of a state vis-a -vis the control over the state police commissioner among others..what is your position on this?

He has made a very important point because the ambit of control of those who implement security should be reasonably defined at the different levels of need, for, as the basic principle of administrative control suggests, regarding the span of control of someone responsible for a task, such a person must be directly responsible to a single source of control.

However I must float a caveat, we have never heard of a local government chairperson who requires lawful use of a DPO (Divisional Police Officer), or of a state governor who requires the lawful use of a state police commissioner who did not get the required response due to his or her authority. Moreover, the most strident opposition to the devolution of policing powers has unfortunately come from those who most need the devolution.

My view is that we should devolve policing powers on local issues to give elected people at lower levels sufficient leverage on security, allowing state and local governments to invest appropriately in security infrastructure according to local needs, but we cannot dispense with a national police service at our current developmental stage.

 How best do you think the public anger against security vote can be doused?
Security is expensive, to train, deploy and maintain a single security personnel is not a cheap exercise, let alone a detachment of troops, but to do so must be effective and the process of doing it should not be opaque; besides, if you are doing so to secure people why should they not know what it costs and how you have expended resources to achieve it?

Nonetheless, to douse public anger, first, expenditure on security should be effective, then  the appropriate personnel to address security issues should be used when dealing with  security challenges; let  the security personnel do their part, but where you require sociologists, psychologists, judicial expertise,  economic and political decisions, the right people should be brought in; the use of force is only one aspect of conflict management, if we do not have such a paradigmatic approach, we would find ourselves using a motor saw when what is required is a lancet. Second, security is what we do together ultimately, and I believe, therefore, that, at the root of our insecurity, is the inability to have a common understanding of who we are as a people; we are too suspicious of ourselves and hence we protect the wrong people amongst us for the wrong reasons.

If we share common values and accept the areas where we have necessary differences, it will be easier to pick out the deviants who aim to destroy all of us. When we do that, we can be like the Bostonians in the USA who all stood together, locked down their state just to pick out a few people who refused to share their common needs for security which foster prosperity. But, ironically,in Nigeria  at the early stages of this Boko Haram insurgency, we saw how the same people that security men were risking their lives to protect hailed and celebrated the killing of security men and the bombing of police stations. Could the Boston bombers  been killed and the other arrested if the people had not co-operated with the security services ?

Tagged : No tags for this article

Headlines Newsview all

INEC Announces Nigeian Elections Will Continue Tomorrow

INEC just announced via its newly created Twitter account for alerts @INECAlert that elections will be postponed till tomorrow in some polling units. This affects ... Full story

Bomb Blast At Polling Station In Enugu State

There was pandemonium today as two bombs were detonated at the WTC primary school polling station in Enugu North local government area by operatives of ... Full story

32 Year Guy Fell In Love With A Woman Sixty Years Older Than Himself

A man who fell in love with a woman sixty years older than himself has told of his special relationship with her that transcended age. It ... Full story

Children Spotted In Line Getting Accredited To Vote In Katsina State

A young boy clearly under the age of 18 had just been photographed by a voter in Katsina state getting his finger prints read by ... Full story

I’m Single And Searching, May D Confirms Breakup With Baby Mama

May D has confirmed to HipTv that he has moved on from his babymama and he is definitely single and still browsing (using the exact ... Full story

Pastor Madubuko Suffering In His Marriage With Emmy Kosgey Silently

Reports emerging from Nigeria indicate that all might not be well with Emmy Kosgey following the history of her rich pastor husband with women. A ... Full story

Jennifer Lopez And Toyboy Casper Smart Seen Kissing in LA

Jennifer Lopez and toyboy Casper Smart are supposedly back together after the couple were spotted kissing backstage at her American Idol season 14 taping in ... Full story

Nigerian Stars, Kunle Afolayan, Banky W And Others Spotted At Polling Stations

Our celebrities seem to be really eager to show their fans ways of being a patriotic Nigerians. Some of them are already out queuing to cast ... Full story

Nollywood Actress, Omoni Oboli- Dont Be Influenced By Money

Omoni Oboli, Nollywood diva and mother of three awesome boys also has some piece of advise for Nigerians as they cast their votes today. The delectable ... Full story

One killed In Osun Violence

The 2015 presidential elections have kicked off and so far it has been going on peacefully except in some states such as Enugu and Osun ... Full story

APC Presidential Candidate Accredited In Daura

Accreditation of Voters is underway at Kofar Baru 3 in Sarkin Yara “A” in Daura Local Government Area. Of Katsina State. Presidential candidate of All Progressives ...

Comment on: We Can Decentralise The Police Without Compromising National Security - Mike Igini

Rate this article

0

Breaking News

ELECTION 2015: Guy Proposes To His Girlfriend At Polling Unit

He Has Decided : Guy Proposes To His Girlfriend At Polling Unit #NigeriaDecides2015Just saw this story on twitter and it got me laughing …. but ...

I Am Using Myself to Correct Bad Impressions About Actresses ...Mercy Johnson

Nollywood actress, Mercy Johnson, has called on fans and colleagues to always have trust and true love for their husband if they want their marriage ...

For My Home to be Strong, I Can’t Marry an Actress...Desmond

Nollywood actor, Diamond Oke¬chi aka Alobam, has joined the league of actors who have declined any intentions of settling down with their female colleagues in ...

Sandra Muna Korie Grabs Beauty Queen’s Boobs

Well, he’s not really grabbing it, but you can see where his hand is…hehe. That’s Sandra Muna Korie, Most Beautiful Face in Nigeria Amity winner. ... Full story

Election 2015: Muma Gee Escapes Assassination In Rivers State

Actress singer and performer turned politician Muma Gee Eke who had earlier dumped PDP to Labour party reportedly escaped an assassination attempt on her life ...

2015: Mixed Reactions Trail Polling Units During Accreditation

As Nigeria decides who will be the president for the next four years, the different centers designated for the accreditation process are having people experience ...

2015 Election: Praiz Postpones UK Tour, Apologies To Fan

Talented vocalist and musician, Praiz, has postponed his UK tour. The reason is not far-fetched, as it might likely be linked to the on going 2015 ...

Eniola Aluko Puts Her law Career On Hold

Nigerian born-England striker, Eniola Aluko has expressed her intentions to put her law career on hold as she focuses on full time football. The 28-year old ... Full story

Don't Be Swayed By Money- Omoni Oboli Advises Voters

Omoni Oboli, Nollywood diva and mother of three awesome boys also has some piece of advise for Nigerians as they cast their votes today. The delectable ...

Election Day Fever, Iyanya Prays For Nigeria

Finally, the must anticipated election day is here. Today, March 28, 2015, Nigerians would decide who would be their leader for the next four years.On that ...